[illumos-Developer] 248 mdnsd fails to run inside zone due to broken code

Garrett D'Amore garrett at nexenta.com
Sun Sep 26 23:21:04 PDT 2010


On Sun, 2010-09-26 at 22:48 -0400, Richard Lowe wrote:
> Garrett D'Amore wrote:
> > Makefile:  remove #ident on line 24
> 
> Doh. 
> 
> > mDNSUNP.c: can we please remove the expanded $Log$ at line 23?  And line
> > 21 while we're at it?   In general it would appear that this code was
> > imported without any conformance to cstyle or other typical ON
> > guidelines.  That suggests that there is an upstream that should be
> > notified of the change?  (If we're not sync'ing with the upstream, then
> > we should bite the bullet and clean the non-applicable #ifdefs up, and
> > also fix the style.  We can do that later, if you file a CR to indicate
> > it.)
> 
> Upstream is Apple, who don't have the Solaris modifications at all and
> so are not affected.  Yes, that's why the source is not beaten into
> format.  They do (more recently) have what appears to be different
> Solaris support.

Hmmm.. interesting.

> I'd prefer to decide re: style changes later, Apple are updating this
> code, and I'd prefer not to make taking changes from the upstream harder
> than necessary.

Ok, if we're still keeping in sync with the upstream, that's fine.

> 
> Was your wanting the $Log$ removed in the context of this, or a separate
> desire regardless of other formatting?

I think we can and should remove $Log$ regardless.  Its stale, and hence
inaccurate.  It doesn't really add to any merge headaches, and so I
can't see a reason to retain it.

	- Garrett





More information about the Developer mailing list